Table of Contents

Guidelines for Designing Peer Activities

Maeve O'Hara Updated by Maeve O'Hara

Students want more peer collaboration, but our courses are short and self-paced, and students start on different dates in different time zones. That makes it hard to get two classmates into the same conversation. An audit of peer activities in current courses found that the method a course uses decides most of what can go wrong. Methods that don’t need a classmate on a schedule had the fewest problems. Facilitator pairing produced most of the issues, including students retaking the course when a partner never showed.

Use the "Methods at a glance" table to gain a quick understanding of the various peer activities, and use the Table of Contents at right to find complete setup details on any method listed.

1. Methods at a glance

Use when you design a peer or partner activity: any activity where students practice with, give feedback to, or work with another person.

SIM then discussion

Outside partner

Discussion board

FeedbackFruits

Live sessions

Facilitator pairs partners

Canvas Groups

What students do

Practice with a SIM, then discuss what they learned with classmates and apply it in the project

Practice with someone outside the course (coworker, friend), then submit a written reflection as an assignment or discussion

Post a piece of work in a discussion and classmates reply with feedback.

Submit a draft, and the tool assigns classmates to review it

Join a facilitator-led Zoom session where pairs work in breakout rooms, then debrief

Students complete a time zone survey in the first module. The facilitator matches each student with a classmate based on the responses. Partners meet on their own, then debrief in a discussion or submit an assignment individually. 

Students complete a time zone survey in the first module. The facilitator builds Canvas Groups from the responses. Students work together in the group’s discussion board or meet on their own. 

Best when

Students can practice and get feedback on their own, plus a human layer

The skill doesn't need a classmate (coaching, counseling, interviewing)

Students need feedback on a piece of work (pitch, draft, setup)

Students need structured peer review of drafts

The exercise needs a counterpart with a confidential role, and a facilitator can host

Students need to work with one partner. Exercises that use confidential roles (for example, negotiations). 

Students need to work with more than one partner, and the submission is a group effort. Exercises that use confidential roles (for example, negotiations).

Classmate needed

No

No

Yes

Yes

Yes, in session

Yes, on a schedule

Yes, on a schedule

Facilitator effort

Low

Low

Low

High

Medium

High

High. Multi-step setup, rebalancing after drops

Student effort

Low to medium

Medium

Low to medium

Medium

Medium

High

High

Risk if a partner is missing

None

Low

Low

Low

Low

High

High

Evidence of completion

Discussion post

Written reflection only

Posts and replies in the discussion

Tool tracks submissions and reviews

Attendance and debrief

Discussion post or assignment

Posts in the group discussion board or group assignment

Example courses

CALS214

LSM584, CHE103, LSM704

SHA692, WCM101

LSM717, AAP105

ILR522

LSM571–576, LSM611

LSM606, LSM586, LSM571–576

2. Considerations for each method

These points vary by method, and not all apply to every activity.

  1. Clear logistics in the student instructions: Who the partner is or how to find one, when and where assignments appear, how to meet, what to record or note, and what to submit and where. For partners in different time zones, leave enough time between pairing and the due date.
  2. Clear instructions in the AA Facilitator Notes page: You must provide clear but concise instructions for the peer activity set up for the facilitator. Test the instructions out to make sure they work.
  3. Link to the project: What students produce in the peer activity is what they use next in the project. Name the peer step on both the activity page and the project part, and keep the wording in sync so it’s clear they build on each other.
  4. Build up to it: Put smaller steps first: an ungraded practice round, solo exercises, or research and a planning conversation. These should scaffold towards the peer activity.
  5. The assignment survives a missing peer: If a partner never shows, the student should still be able to finish the assignment. Where that isn't possible, there is a fallback that says what students do if they can't find a partner, or a partner drops or goes quiet, and by when.
  6. Early, repeated reminders: Mention the activity on the Welcome page, the Preview Your Course Project page (if applicable), and the module intro before the activity. Consider custom announcements for the course.
  7. Ensure video submissions are captioned: If students submit or post video or audio, captions are required to meet accessibility guidelines. Student-generated videos posted to discussion boards will have captions generated automatically within 24 hours.
  8. Permission for recording: If students record someone outside of the course, tell them to get permission and follow local recording laws. Whether the activity needs consent or confidentiality guidance is the faculty member's call.

3. Method profiles

SIM, then discussion

Overview

Students practice with a SIM, then discuss what they learned with classmates. What they take from the SIM feeds into the next step of the project.

Best for

Debriefing low-stakes practice with peers. 

Facilitator effort

Low. Discussion and/or project grading. 

Student effort

Low to medium. Complete the SIM, post, and revise in the project.

Setup

SIM + discussion + project (or other variations)

Considerations

Provide a fallback for students who don’t post to the discussion in time 

Example courses

CALS214

Outside partner

Overview

Students practice with someone outside the course (coworker, friend, family member) on their own, then submit a written account or reflection as a discussion or part of a project.

Best for

Skills that don't need a classmate: coaching, counseling, interviewing, brainwriting.

Facilitator effort

Low. Feedback on submissions only.

Student effort

Medium. Find a partner, schedule a session, take notes, and complete the assignment.  

Setup

  • Provide reminders to line up a partner early in the course
  • Provide a template tool to guide their work with their partner, e.g., an interview guide, coaching journal, etc.
  • Students use the tool or their notes to complete the discussion or project part.
  • Provide a fallback line: "If you can't find a partner, contact your instructor as soon as possible."

Considerations

  • Facilitators only see the submitted assignment, so the prompt needs to ask for detail.
  • Recording peer interactions outside the course raises confidentiality and privacy concerns. Try to avoid if at all possible.
  • Tie this activity to a project or a discussion. Students are unlikely to do it if it’s ungraded.

Example courses

LSM584, DNS510/530, CHE102, CHE103, CALS213, LSM704, LSM401

FeedbackFruits peer review

Overview

Students submit a draft and the tool assigns reviewers. 

Best for

Structured peer review of drafts.

Facilitator effort

High. Set phase dates for every new section; monitor to ensure it’s working correctly; troubleshoot issues with students; grade and provide feedback. 

Student effort

Medium. Submit a draft by the deadline and review classmates' drafts.

Setup

  • Make it an ungraded activity followed by a debrief discussion or a debrief project part (see AAP105).
  • Set the phase dates for every new section before the course opens.
  • Document setup in the AA Facilitator Notes, with instructions.
  • Don't duplicate or copy the activity.
  • See the HelpDocs article on FeedbackFruits Implementation.

Considerations

You must provide a fallback for students who miss feedback rounds. Provide a self-review or an alternative assignment. Include detailed instructions for this in the AA Facilitator Notes. 

Example courses

LSM717, AAP105

Live sessions

Overview

The facilitator runs scheduled Zoom sessions and assigns pairs in breakout rooms. If using confidential roles, the facilitator provides each student with their role in advance.

Best for

Exercises that need a counterpart with or without a confidential role, when a facilitator can host.

Facilitator effort

Medium. Run the sessions, email roles, assign breakout pairs.

Student effort

Medium. Attend a scheduled session.

Setup

  • Clear instructions for students
  • Clear for facilitators
  • If using confidential roles, instruct facilitators to send them privately before the session.

Considerations

Provide a fallback for students who can’t attend the live session. 

Example courses

ILR522 (high NPS, 76.3)

Facilitator pairs classmates individually 

Overview

The facilitator matches students from a time zone survey and sends assignments. Partners meet on their own for a live exercise (Zoom or otherwise), then submit an individual assignment in Canvas. 

Best for

Students who need to work with one partner; exercises that use confidential roles, for example, negotiations.

Facilitator effort

High. Survey review, matching, messaging each pair, check-in, and reassigning no-shows and drops.

Student effort

High. Complete the survey, coordinate across time zones, hold the session, and complete the assignment.

Setup

In the course

  • A setup module at the start with the time zone survey and an overview of the peer activity with clear instructions.
  • Student instructions with where to find their partner and how to contact them

In the facilitator notes

  • Provide one way in which facilitators pair students and they use that every time.
  • A deadline for pairing students that facilitators can meet.
  • A solution for students who don't answer the time zone survey.
  • A plan for student drops and no-shows: who checks, when, and the reassignment options. Canvas doesn't flag a dropped student.
  • Planned reminders (announcement or short personal video).

Considerations

Avoid sign-up sheets or using the Student Lounge as the main way to match students. 

Example courses

LSM586, LSM606, LSM611, CREA502

Canvas groups

Overview

Students complete a time zone survey, and the facilitator builds Canvas Groups from the responses. Students then work together in the group’s discussion board or via video conference. Groups can be pairs, trios, or small teams.

Best for

Students need to work with more than one partner, and the submission is a group effort. Exercises that use confidential roles (for example, negotiations).

Facilitator effort

High. Review the survey, build the groups, check that each group’s page works, rebalance after drops, and notify students who are moved. 

Student effort

Medium. Complete the survey, find their group, and post to the group’s board.

Setup

In the course

  • A time zone survey in the first module, due by a stated date.
  • Student instructions on where to find their group, how to communicate (via discussion board or video conference), and how to submit the work.

In the facilitator notes

  • Provide one way facilitators pair students, and use it every time.
  • A deadline for pairing students that facilitators can meet.
  • A solution for students who don't answer the time zone survey.
  • A plan for student drops and no-shows: who checks, when, and the reassignment options. Canvas doesn't flag a dropped student.
  • Planned reminders (announcement or short personal video).

Considerations

Avoid sign-up sheets or using the Student Lounge as the main way to match students.

Example courses

LSM571–576

How did we do?

The Pocket Guide to Instructional Design Thinking at eCornell

Adding AER to Canvas